Evaluation

Evaluation 

 

Firstly, my idea, evaluating my idea is difficult because I failed at the first hurdle. The idea that I didn’t fulfil. Originally the idea that I went with was the magazine and podcast. This ended up being just the magazine. 

 

Overall, it’s hard to evaluate and understand why this happened. I think overall conducting an interview for the magazine almost replaced the podcast. The type of questions I asked, and topics discussed were exactly what would have been discussed in the podcast. It’s important to remember that when creating an idea to try stick to it as best you can, however In this case due to not being able to set up a physical podcast using good sound quality microphones and already conducting an interview it may have actually benefited my project to not have a podcast, it may have brought the project down in overall terms of quality. 

 

On the subject of my ideas I am extremely happy with how my PowerPoint pitch and presentation went. It gave me excellent feedback and helped with research source ideas and exactly what pages I needed for my magazine. It helped my presenting and confidence and my project overall. 

 

In the future like I mentioned earlier it’s important to stick to your idea even if it’s in turmoil presenting something over nothing may be the smarter choice. This time it went okay and I’m happy however for the next project I complete I’m definitely going to only choose one idea over two and stick to it.

 

Secondly my planning, when planning I always tend to find it difficult to completely plan out my entire project. However, in this instance it was extremely difficult given the pandemic situation. My planning of specific parts of the project were good, especially the interview. The questions I had planned out worked well and allowed follow up questions.

 

Alongside this the planning of the shoot went rather well, selecting different locations helped gravitate my project to the next level. Even if they weren’t specific locations the rough idea gave me enough to collect a good variation of shots for my final piece and my strong planning supported this. The added addition of planning documents also helped my project as it enabled me to know the equipment, I needed through a production checklist and using a location recce and storyboard really helped vary my shots and choose specific locations.

 

So, in reality my planning did wonders for my project however there were also some negatives. One issue with my planning is that in almost every project and especially this one is a general timescale. Having a plan for your shots, equipment and everything else is good however in my future projects I really need to develop an action plan that lasts the entire project. It needs to include the dates of when I’m doing each stage of the project and when I would like to complete certain areas by. Updating this throughout the project for re-schedules and ticking off parts completed would aid me massively.

 

Another thing for the future could be completing even more planning documents to help aid my project further two examples could be a casting sheet and a mood board.

 

Thirdly my research. Research is always hard for me to evaluate. Particularly because one of my five channels are useless. Although the podcast idea was dropped, I still carried out a channel of research on it which is unfortunate, but I think my other four channels made up for it. Thankfully the four channels on magazines were evenly balanced with two being primary and two secondary.

 

As I previously mentioned from the evaluation of my ideas page, the feedback that I should look at a private study of GQ magazine really helped me with this project. As it was research that had already been completed I could just cherry pick the best bits to help me with my project, extremely useful. It helped me especially with my typeface and colour scheme. This and with my own research into GQ you can see just how much my work is influenced by these when you look at it. For example, I feel like I stuck to the codes and conventions of magazines well on the front cover of my piece, this all spins off from my research. A quick example could be the logo staying in the same place for every magazine and continuing that in my own project. 

 

Analysing my primary research, the SurveyMonkey was good but the feedback and pointers I made for myself I didn't really act on. Something I definitely need to have a look at the next project. The focus group was very good and provided feedback that I constantly referenced back to as the project was going on and it helped that the members knew quite a lot about the chosen subject this is a reminder that selecting the members of the focus group is key.

 

Now finally a general analysis of my production and the project as a whole. First of all I’m going to discuss the codes and conventions I have stuck to and broken. Beginning with the front cover I stuck to the codes and conventions rather well. Examples of this would include the background close up image, logo, text and barcode. Like I explained on my production page there were a lot of issues with this front cover especially the background image. It affected my piece as it made me differ from my planning and research which was frustrating as following planning and research is key to a good project. In future I’m going to ensure that when shooting I know exactly what I am shooting for and capture studio quality images. Also work on my postproduction by either getting help from others or researching beforehand not when I’m in the postproduction stage. Selecting and cutting the background image really slowed down and affected my project. 

 

The contents page, I’m happy with I feel like I broke out of the usual codes and conventions but kept in check with what would be the fundamentals of a normal contents page. Page numbers and what is on that page is essential on a contents because readers come there for those essentials, however the way I changed the style of this and added images and split up the page to make it more interesting. The production was simple enough there are improvements that could be made. An example is the images I used not all of them are related to what’s on the page. The reasoning behind this was because I wanted to only use original images throughout my production. Looking back, I could have kept up this theme however as I completed the contents page last, I didn’t have time to gather more images related to the subject of the page.  Another slight disappointment of the contents is the type face shortening the amount of text and making it stand out more is a top priority for another project of this nature.  

 

Finally, the double page spread, this page also unfortunately misses some key contexts and characteristics. Firstly, in my research and from looking at magazines at the beginning of a section of text the first letter is always largened in size to show where the text begins. I did try and do this with several different sizes, typefaces and movements but I just couldn’t get it right and looking professional. The page numbers also look slightly amateur.

 

Changes made after feedback-When finishing the first drafts of my three pages I sent them to different members of my target audience for feedback. For the front page when I completed my first draft, I was told that having the GQ logo in black and orange could be improved by changing to white and orange, I made the change according to my audience and it improved my project. I didn’t receive much more feedback apart from praise and positives. I was told to slightly downsize the pictures on my contents page and did so but it was a minor tweak and didn’t impact my project massively. 

 

I think my three pieces work well as a set and wouldn’t be out of place from the professional standpoint. They met my chosen target audience that I presented in my research through the images used, easy design to follow on the contents page and down to earth interview. There were of course issues with this project, dropping the podcast and struggling in post-production most notable. 

 

Overall, I am very happy with how this project went given the circumstances, in this case a global pandemic I was still able to produce good production that I was happy with. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

  1. FORMATIVE : You have uploaded your design to your blogger Production page. Double page spread is excellent. Don’t forget to apply design theory in your piece. Research sources of other author’s opinions and their design style in the future. Also… did you study lighting technique juxtapositioned with theory in your research? Show this in your next project.

    ReplyDelete
  2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3W2TxJTFok

    ReplyDelete
  3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVRBWXuVcUk

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment